Shoeing isn’t always helping, and more farriers are quietly admitting it.
Horse shoes have been around for centuries, but tradition doesn’t always mean better. More equine professionals and hoof experts are speaking out about the long-term effects nailed-on shoes have on a horse’s health, especially in everyday riding situations. While they may seem protective, they often do more harm than good. If you think horseshoes are just fancy accessories, here’s the part that might change your mind completely.
1. Nails disrupt natural hoof structure from the inside out.
Pounding nails into a living hoof wall sounds questionable for a reason—it compromises structural integrity. The hoof wall is meant to flex and absorb shock, but nails can weaken those natural mechanics. As reported by The Horse, repeated shoeing causes micro-damage over time, leaving the hoof more brittle and vulnerable. Every reset adds more wear, and the more you mess with the hoof wall, the more you risk long-term deformities. A “small poke” has a much bigger impact than it seems.
2. Circulation takes a hit when metal limits movement.
Healthy hooves expand and contract slightly with each step, aiding blood flow and shock absorption. Shoes stiffen that process. That restricted movement leads to reduced circulation, which can impact everything from growth to recovery. According to research in the Journal of Equine Veterinary Science, hooves without shoes maintain significantly better perfusion. When blood flow drops, healing slows, sensitivity rises, and discomfort builds under the surface—literally.
3. Horseshoes can actually worsen traction in natural terrain.
It sounds backwards, but metal-on-dirt isn’t the grippy combo most riders think it is. Hooves evolved for varied surfaces like grass, sand, and rock. Metal shoes often cause slipping in mud and hardpan, especially if not fitted with studs or traction devices. As discovered by researchers from the University of Zurich, barefoot horses often outperform shod horses on complex terrain due to the hoof’s natural grip and flexibility. That natural tread exists for a reason, and we’ve been nailing over it for too long.
4. The frog can’t function properly when the shoe lifts it off the ground.
That triangle-shaped pad on the bottom of the hoof isn’t just a weird growth—it’s the frog, and it’s critical. It acts like a shock absorber and helps pump blood through the lower leg. Shoes often raise the hoof enough that the frog barely makes contact, making it less effective. Without stimulation, it weakens over time. A neglected frog can cause everything from poor circulation to uneven gait, and the horse loses one of its most important shock-control systems.
5. Barefoot hooves adapt and strengthen in ways shoes prevent.
Horses allowed to go barefoot often develop thicker soles and tougher hoof walls, which gradually make them more resilient to all kinds of terrain. Shoes act like crutches that limit this adaptation. Owners who pull shoes and transition their horses to barefoot riding often see improvement in overall hoof quality within months. The trick is giving the hoof time to do what it’s built to do without constant interference.
6. Incorrect shoeing jobs cause more damage than going barefoot.
Not all farriers are equal, and a poorly placed shoe can throw off your horse’s entire limb alignment. One slightly misaligned angle or over-trimmed heel gets magnified with every step. Long-term damage to joints, tendons, and ligaments often starts with subtle shoeing errors. Even shoes applied with the best intentions can cause more trouble than they prevent when used repeatedly on hooves that weren’t built for them.
7. Hoof infections are more common under nailed-on shoes.
Moisture gets trapped between the shoe and the hoof wall, creating the perfect breeding ground for bacteria and fungi. Thrush, white line disease, and abscesses thrive in these tight, dark environments. Cleaning and inspecting the hoof becomes harder when the structure is partially hidden, which means infections often go unnoticed until they’re severe. The very thing meant to protect the foot often makes it harder to keep clean and healthy.
8. Many horses perform better barefoot than expected.
People assume performance horses need shoes, but that’s not always true. Jumpers, endurance athletes, and trail horses are competing and working barefoot more than ever. With proper conditioning, most horses adapt quickly and perform at or above their previous level. The biggest challenge often isn’t the hoof—it’s changing the human mindset that thinks metal equals better. Once owners see the difference in movement, soundness, and recovery, it’s hard to go back.
e34rjt